Does air con help spread coronavirus? Chinese study of 3 families in a restaurant suggests it

Coronavirus / COVID-19-How it is impacting our lives?
April 15, 2020
April 15, 2020
Show all
  • Direction of airflow from air-conditioning ventilation found to be the key factor in what was believed to be droplet transmission
  • Restaurants advised by the researchers to increase the space between table
    A study of 10 cases from three families who dined at the same restaurant in southern China has suggested that air conditioning aided droplet transmission between them.

    “Strong airflow from the air conditioner could have propagated droplets” between three tables, according to the report of the research, based on the infections in the city of Guangzhou in late January. Droplet transmission alone could not explain the infections, it concluded.

    Restaurants should increase the space between tables and improve ventilation to reduce the risk of infection, according to the report of the research, led by Jianyun Lu of the Guangzhou Centre for Disease Control and Prevention.

    The research is revealed in an early-release article for the July edition of Emerging Infectious Diseases, the open-access and peer-reviewed journal published by the Centres for Disease Control and Prevention of the United States.

    Family clusters of infections have helped the spread of a pandemic in which the world’s total cases are approaching 2 million and the death toll has passed 120,000.

    The first patient of the 10 cases studied in Guangzhou had on January 23 returned from Wuhan, where the coronavirus was first reported in December.

    The person had lunch with three family members the next day at a windowless restaurant with an air conditioner on each floor.

    Two other families sat at neighbouring tables, with about one metre between each and an overlap in dining time of about an hour, the report said.

    The first patient had a fever and cough later that day and went to hospital. Within two weeks, four further members of their family, three members of the second family and two of the third family had become ill with Covid-19, the disease caused by the coronavirus.

    After detailed investigation, it was found that the only known source of exposure for the second and third families was the first patient in the restaurant.

    Members of three families became ill after dining close to the first infected person. Graphic: SCMP
    Members of three families became ill after dining close to the first infected person. Graphic: SCMP

    “From our examination of the potential routes of transmission, we concluded that the most likely cause of this outbreak was droplet transmission,” the report said.

    “We conclude that in this outbreak, droplet transmission was prompted by air-conditioned ventilation. The key factor for infection was the direction of the airflow.”

    It said another 73 customers who dined on the same floor were identified as having close contact with the first patient, but were found to have no symptoms of Covid-19 during a 14-day quarantine and provided throat swab samples that tested negative. No staff working at the restaurant were found to be infected.

    Michelin restaurant in Scotland offers self-isolation menu for customers amid coronavirus pandemic

    Six smear samples from the air conditioner’s outlet and inlet all tested nucleotide negative, it said.

    “This finding is less consistent with aerosol transmission,” the report said. “However, aerosols would tend to follow the airflow, and the lower concentrations of aerosols at greater distances might have been insufficient to cause infection in other parts of the restaurant.

    Coronavirus can travel twice as far as official ‘safe distance’, study says
    11 Mar 2020

    “To prevent the spread of the virus in restaurants, we recommend increasing the distance between tables and improving ventilation.”

    The Guangzhou team stated that the research had limitations because they did not conduct an experimental study simulating the airborne transmission route, nor perform antibody studies of swab sample-negative, asymptomatic family members and other diners to estimate the risk of infection from them.

    Article Source:-

Leave a Reply